Newspapers: Fear and Loathing in Social Media

by Laurel Papworth on December 10, 2009 · 47 comments

At Media140 I said mentioned that journalists (well some, anyway) weren’t really members of the social networks, just using them to lift stories, out of context, with no respect for the online community family. Or, weirdly, move between the two – sometimes mucking around with the rest of us on Twitter, the next minute lifting content to ridicule in heritage media channels. It’s annoying when a joke or a miffed tweet meant to be human interaction becomes front page News. From Marieke Hardy of Triple J on ABC NEWS

triple 7That’s right, I reserve my most sophisticated material for between 6:00am and 9:00am weekdays. For the most part this jolly little activity has been nothing more than a harmless attempt to “save” the “gold” for “on-air”, until two weeks ago when Triple J staff chanced upon a full-page picture of retiring NSW newsreader Ian Ross and considered what fun it might be to keep up the exhaustingly amusing tradition.

One of my co-presenters “did” the tongue, I – in an unbridled act of hilarity – tore little holes in Ian’s eyes and placed my own behind, googly and unblinking and garish. After a few high-spirited minutes and chortling photographs documenting the occasion we went back on air and forgot about it all completely. Until of course roughly two hours later when someone in the office pointed out that we were all of a sudden the lead story on a news website and perhaps it might be prudent of us to address this particular fact sooner rather than later?

There it was, splayed across the Daily Telegraph’s online edition in startling black type: “Channel Seven newsreader Ian Ross humiliated by Triple J in defaced advertisements on Twitter“.

I do wish the media – particularly print – would stop ransacking social media discussions, particularly cannibalizing their own, to sell newspapers. Not only does it make me doubt the sanity of Murdoch, who insists on paywalls, wanting to find new ways to sell our own stories back to us as News but it makes me wonder why we ever paid $2 bucks and change for Advertising, Press Releases and Beat Up Stories.

While the giddying lack of time between social networking event and breaking story has become increasingly unremarkable, the lust for a dirty scandal has surely reached ridiculous proportions.

Are the media honestly so hungry for a chance to stomp around shouting THIS IS AN OUTRAGE and STOP THIS SICK STUNT and other such self-important catchphrases that they are uncovering disrepute where there is, in fact, none to be found? And as a result of this will those who have any involvement in the media now limit their daily activities to a spot of tea and a digestive biscuit lest they too are dragged kicking and screaming into the mire?

It will come as no surprise to you, dear Reader, that newspapers now employ social media watchers, looking for a slip of the tongue, a naughty tweet, something that can be misdirected, misrepresented and spun into a scandal.

Consider this: Either we are self publishing online and “should know that everything is fair game” OR we are members of a community passing news around with due respect to the rules and rituals of that community.

For me, I’m never impressed with those that take a tweet or piece of content out of context and use their publishing power to bully or intimidate. What do you think?

PS I’m not lovin’ the Xmas theme, might be gone sooner rather than later.  Ho Ho bloody ho.

Buzz it!

Popularity: 5% [?]

Bookmark This:
  • email
  • Add to favorites
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • StumbleUpon
  • del.icio.us
  • LinkedIn
  • TwitThis
  • Technorati
  • Digg
  • Live
  • Google Bookmarks
  • NewsVine
  • Tumblr
  • Reddit
  • MySpace
  • Slashdot
  • Netvibes

Technorati Tags: , , , , , , ,

Related posts

39 Tweets 18 Other Comments

{ 47 comments… read them below or add one }

1 Delperro December 10, 2009 at 8:30 am

I agree Laurel, (in spite of your tiny little typo in the last sentence). It’s not only print media though see: http://www.vexnews.com/news/4002/lipstick-on-a-pig-cfmeu-spin-doctor-jesse-dean-lifts-lid-on-her-secret-life-of-licentious-lefty-luxury/

While we’re members of the community following the rules, the less ethical media has always done this.

Reply

2 Jason Whittaker December 10, 2009 at 10:19 am

A little churlish, Laurel, to talk about newspapers nicking conversations from social media, when so much of social media discussion is built around links to traditional media…

And what you’re essentially talking about is not some trend to mine social media, simply examples of cheap, crap journalism. There’s just new ways to do it. There’s always been crap journalism, and unfortunately there always will be. Thankfully the interweb delivers us plenty of quality reporting from very fine journalists if you want to go looking for it…

Reply   More from author

3 Laurel Papworth December 10, 2009 at 10:30 am

yeah I thought about that. Trad media writes about human activity. We write about trad media and human activity. Bloggers also write about each others blogs. It’s a web of creator, responder, commenter.

I guess the point I’m making – and maybe not clearly? – is that communities expect and usually receive respect. Bloggers tear shreds off each other’s ideas, but it’s not continual linkbait, unless it’s personal. Linkbait I think is bloggers term for “if it bleeds, it leads”. These types of articles which look personal to the victim are really an impersonal form of linkbaiting, selling more subscriptions, copies.

A business reality for newspapers but takes away from their historical mandate as “news server to the community” and becomes “preyer on the community”. Is that too harsh?

It probably is – because we are at fault. Why is crap journalism so well read – mainstream newspapers and photoshopped women’s magazines top the circulation list, rather than something a bit more erudite. Even the shock jock bloggers do better in the short term with crap journogging (journalist that blog sensationalist material).
Beats me.

Reply

4 John Lacey December 10, 2009 at 11:17 am

Did you see this little social-media-faux-pas story from The Age (another publication I understand that the aforementioned Marieke Hardy writes for)? Qantas mouthpiece tweets all over Jetstar

Reply   More from author

5 Jason Whittaker December 10, 2009 at 11:31 am

Laurel,

I think it’s much simpler than that. I’d make the point that crap journalism is NOT a new trend. It’s existed for as long as the media has. I get fed up with new media campaigners and social media experts reading the Daily Telegraph gossip column and deciding all media is rotten. No, the Daily Telegraph is rotten – there’s plenty of quality stuff out there, and it’s never been easier to access. Don’t tar all journalists and all ‘traditional’ reporting models with the same brush. Much of it is good, and much of it is STILL the best model for upholding those fourth estate principles that remain vital.

As I said, exploitative journalism has been around since the printing press. Online networks are merely the new medium for gathering it.

Reply   More from author

6 Craig Pearce December 11, 2009 at 5:09 am

Laurel, the media’s bread and butter is to take information ‘out of context and use their publishing power to bully or intimidate’, no matter whether it is social media or not. Sadly, those in social media are going to have to get used to that and, probably, contextualise their content in this knowledge.

Conversely, high-minded/aspirational social media principles can be adhered to and, over time, this may influence the less principled elements of traditional media.

I wouldn’t be holding your breath, though….

Reply   More from author

7 Blerk December 10, 2009 at 12:52 am

Is there going to be a demo?

This comment was originally posted on VG247

Reply   More from author

8 Neolucifer December 10, 2009 at 12:55 am

Are there going to be free dlc ?

What about a joe madureira artbook in some collector edition ?

This comment was originally posted on VG247

Reply

9 Stephany Nunneley December 10, 2009 at 1:10 am

Good job guys! Keep em coming.

This comment was originally posted on VG247

Reply   More from author

10 The Hindle December 10, 2009 at 1:13 am

How much Exploration is there in the game?

This comment was originally posted on VG247

Reply

11 Blerk December 10, 2009 at 1:15 am

What kind of length are we looking at (matron)?

The footage shown so far looks very action-oriented, but they keep saying it’s almost Zelda-like. What’s on offer besides the action? And why aren’t we seeing some of that too?

This comment was originally posted on VG247

Reply   More from author

12 bobbymington December 10, 2009 at 1:19 am

are they worried about releasing on the same day as bayonetta?

This comment was originally posted on VG247

Reply   More from author

13 bobbymington December 10, 2009 at 1:22 am

Is there a sequel planned?

This comment was originally posted on VG247

Reply   More from author

14 DANTHEMAN December 10, 2009 at 1:25 am

seeing that there is Playstation Home outfits coming will there be a Home Space aswell?

This comment was originally posted on VG247

Reply

15 bobbymington December 10, 2009 at 1:28 am

Will there be several beasts you can change into is it just the one.

This comment was originally posted on VG247

Reply   More from author

16 bobbymington December 10, 2009 at 1:33 am

will you be able to swim or does water = instant death

This comment was originally posted on VG247

Reply   More from author

17 Gekidami December 10, 2009 at 1:53 am

People only really heard about this game when it started to get good reviews, whats their opinion on Darksiders overall lack of coverage and hype?

This comment was originally posted on VG247

Reply

18 Stephany Nunneley December 10, 2009 at 1:53 am

Thanks loads. Questions sent.

This comment was originally posted on VG247

Reply   More from author

19 yaya mar December 10, 2009 at 2:14 am

any collectors edition ??

This comment was originally posted on VG247

Reply

20 FeaturePreacher December 10, 2009 at 5:01 am

1. Are there any other melee weapons besides the sword?

2. If there are other melee weapons is there swift(meaning press a single button once) weapon switching while playing the game?

3. Are there other projectile weapons besides the gun?

4. If there are other projectile weapons besides the gun, is there swift(meaning press a single button once) weapon switching while playing the game.

5. Are there counter attacks? More specifically, if you time a certain action to occur just at the moment an npc strikes, will the player do a unique move that puts him at an advantage to follow up with a sequence of strikes?

6. How many levels of upgrades to the character and his weapons have?

7. Can low level NPCs be dismembered without a quick time event?

8. Are there ways to reflect projectiles NPCs shoot towards you back to the NPC that shot the projectile or other NPCs nearby?

9. Can the character disarm NPCs that have weapons and use those weapons?

10. Is there any vertical or horizontal wall running?

11. What abilities does the horse have other than being a conveyance?

12. Does the main character get any other companions besides the horse?

13. Wouldn’t this game have better sales prospects if it was released from April-August 2009 so it didn’t have to compete with Bayonetta, Dante’s Inferno, or God Of War 3? This game looks good and looks like a worthy purchase, but there’s a version of Bayonetta that got a perfect score from Famitsu and the notoriously hard to impress Edge magazine. It seems to me that this good looking game would have even better sales prospects if it had less fierce competition.

This comment was originally posted on VG247

Reply

21 FeaturePreacher December 10, 2009 at 5:01 am

1. Are there any other melee weapons besides the sword?

2. If there are other melee weapons is there swift(meaning press a single button once) weapon switching while playing the game?

3. Are there other projectile weapons besides the gun?

4. If there are other projectile weapons besides the gun, is there swift(meaning press a single button once) weapon switching while playing the game.

5. Are there counter attacks? More specifically, if you time a certain action to occur just at the moment an npc strikes, will the player do a unique move that puts him at an advantage to follow up?

6. How many levels of upgrades to the character and his weapons are there?

7. Can low level NPCs be dismembered without a quick time event?

8. Are there ways to reflect projectiles NPCs shoot towards you back to the NPC that shot the projectile or other NPCs nearby?

9. Can the character disarm NPCs that have weapons and use those weapons?

10. Is there any vertical or horizontal wall running?

11. What abilities does the horse have other than being a conveyance?

12. Wouldn’t this game have better sales prospects if it was released from April-Auguste 2009 so it didn’t have to compete with Bayonetta, Dante’s Inferno, or God Of War 3? There’s a version of Bayonetta that got a perfect score from Famitsu and the notoriously hard to impress Edge magazine.

This comment was originally posted on VG247

Reply

26 Stephany Nunneley December 10, 2009 at 11:22 am

Wow. Just wow. Hat’s off to FeaturePreacher. Hand him a beer and a hooker while your at it. He deserves it. *claps* Seriously. Good job there. Too bad I already sent the questions off

This comment was originally posted on VG247

Reply   More from author

27 FeaturePreacher December 10, 2009 at 4:03 pm

So there’s no chance of sending those questions to them?

This comment was originally posted on VG247

Reply

Leave a Comment

Additional comments powered by BackType

Previous post:

Next post: